My Father

My Father The Judge Toro 6″ x 56

★★★★★★★★★★5 · 1 review

The My Father The Judge Toro, a box-pressed 6 x 56 from the line Cigar Aficionado named its No. 1 cigar of 2024. An Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper over bold Nicaraguan tobaccos: leather, cedar, earth and pepper. Full-bodied, rich and deep from light to nub.

$12.35

Earn 123 points with this order
Sign in to start collecting Reward Points
Sign in

Built from the leaf up

Size and shape
6 x 56
Box-pressed Toro
6″56
Strength
Full
Wrapper
Ecuadorian Sumatra
Oily Sumatra leaf
Origin
Nicaragua
Garcia family, My Father Cigars
Tasting notes
LeatherCedarEarthBlack PepperRoasted Nuts
Smoke time
~80 min
A bold, full-bodied toro
Binder & filler
Nicaraguan binder and filler
Corojo binder, Esteli filler
Pairs with
Bourbon, Espresso, Porter

How it smokes

First third

Leather, cedar, and earth with bold pepper.

Second third

Black pepper arrives alongside earth.

Final third

Roasted nuts hold through the finish.

Fast, discreet shipping
Ships within one business day.
Authenticity guaranteed
Sourced direct, inspected, and genuine.
Packed for freshness
Humidity protection keeps it in ideal condition.
Damage replaced
Anything damaged in transit is replaced. Checkout is encrypted.

Description

A wider 56-ring size, The Judge Toro carries My Father’s full Sumatra blend in a thicker format. The My Father The Judge Toro is built by the García family with a dark Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper over a Nicaraguan Corojo binder and Nicaraguan filler, at a full body.

The flavor usually moves through cocoa, leather, espresso, and black pepper, with the wider ring keeping it cool. At 6 by 56, the box-pressed toro runs a long, slow session.

The full body suits later in the day. It is sold as singles or boxes of 20, so one is a sensible first try. A thick, box-pressed Nicaraguan full-body.

Pairs well with bourbon, espresso, or porter.

Weight N/A
Series

Strength

Wrapper

Origin

Shape

Length

Ring Gauge

Filler

Binder

,

Manufacturer

Press

Rolling Method

Wrapper Color

Single Packaging

Complimentary shipping over $99. Adult signature (21+) required. Some shipping restrictions may apply. Arrived damaged? Contact us within 72 hours for a replacement.

Reviews

5.0out of 5
Based on 1 review
1 review
Vishal Mace Maisuria
· Cigar Grail team
One of the best My Father cigars on the market! Unlike the shorter but thicker 60 ring gauge counter part (which was #1 in 2024 for Cigar Afficiando) this toro variant brings you the same full body flavor, rich smoke plum, and lasts in my opinion about 20 to 30 minutes longer. As a fan of big ring gauge cigars, the Judge burns evenly from beginning to finish bringing you notes of cocoa, cedar, pepper, and earthy tobacco in the finish. I recommend this to all medium to full body smokers who want to try My Father and also recommend pairing this with a bourbon as it compliments the notes without taking away from the cigar experience.
  • Liga Undercrown 10 Toro Single

    Liga Undercrown 10 Toro 6″ x 52

    From $12.15
  • Rocky Patel Decade Robusto Single

    Rocky Patel Decade Robusto 5″ x 50

    From $12.35
  • Oscar Valladares Super Fly Maduro Toro Single

    Oscar Valladares Super Fly Maduro Toro 6″ x 54

    From $12.15
  • Casa 1910 Cavalry Edition Jilguero 6 x 60 cigar

    Casa 1910 Cavalry Edition Jilguero 6″ x 60

    From $12.15
  • Casa 1910 Soldadera Edition Teniente Angela Toro 6 x 52 cigar

    Casa 1910 Soldadera Edition Teniente Angela Toro 6″ x 52

    From $12.15
  • My Father No. 5 Toro Single

    My Father No. 5 Toro 6″ x 56

    From $12.25